![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png){kind=small}
Additional Question
Jun. 3rd, 2018 10:30 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
ladybrookeSignups are still on track to open at 11:59 PM UTC on June 4th - so roughly 22 hours from now.
ladybrookeSignups are still on track to open at 11:59 PM UTC on June 4th - so roughly 22 hours from now.
Tagset Progress
Jun. 1st, 2018 09:28 pmladybrookeI am finished reviewing all tags that I do not have questions about.
Update about some group noms, specifically The Kindly Ones: On the basis of the presented info in the last post about that nom, I'm allowing it in as is without specific character names. The same also applies to noms for Group: The Three Ladies (Magic Flute), Group: Shieldmaidens of Rohan (LOTR), and Group: Tar-Míriel & Women of the Faithful, either because the characters lack specific names or because of how they function in their canon. Thank you for everyone who answered last post!
This decision may apply to Group: Jasper & Ruby Squad, if the nominator will contact me with their reasoning - I can't find enough info online to understand exactly how that group works. Accepted
Questions from last post that still need answers:
( Read more... )
New Questions:
1. Group: Kara Danvers (Arrowverse) & Jean Grey (X-Men Movies) - I'm assuming Supergirl for Kara Danvers, but is X-Men Movies Alternate Timeline or Original? As far as I can tell, there's differences between the two sets of movies in terms of the character. Allowed for this year due to mod error.
2.Fandom: October Daye Series; Character Arden Windemere - is there a typo in the character name? I can only find Arden Windermere online. Fixed, thanks!
3. Barbie - All Media Types - This is too broad. Can it be narrowed down to Video Games, Movies, Books, etc, if not a specific movie? Fixed, thanks!
4.Gone With the Wind - All Media Types - This also needs to be narrowed down to Book or Movie. Fixed, thanks!
5. X-Men (Comicverse) - There appear to be a lot of comics with different plotlines/characterization/etc, can this be narrowed to a specific verse?
Since noms are closed, just let me know below or through PMs what needs to be done on any of these. If you want an all media types split into two (so both "Book" and "Movie" for Barbie, for example), that's fine.
Update about some group noms, specifically The Kindly Ones: On the basis of the presented info in the last post about that nom, I'm allowing it in as is without specific character names. The same also applies to noms for Group: The Three Ladies (Magic Flute), Group: Shieldmaidens of Rohan (LOTR), and Group: Tar-Míriel & Women of the Faithful, either because the characters lack specific names or because of how they function in their canon. Thank you for everyone who answered last post!
Questions from last post that still need answers:
( Read more... )
New Questions:
2.
4.
5. X-Men (Comicverse) - There appear to be a lot of comics with different plotlines/characterization/etc, can this be narrowed to a specific verse?
Since noms are closed, just let me know below or through PMs what needs to be done on any of these. If you want an all media types split into two (so both "Book" and "Movie" for Barbie, for example), that's fine.
I am working on associating the remaining 19 unassociated characters/groups with fandoms. If you spot anything missing from the tagset that was nommed and is not one of the above questions or there, please let me know - there's been a few lag issues with Ao3 where I've wondered if something disappeared.
ladybrookeAs a reminder, noms are set to close tomorrow (June 1st) at 11:59 PM UTC. Here is a countdown clock! They definitely will not close before then, they may close a little late if my schedule doesn't work out right - but that just means you all can sneak in some very last minute noms if that happens.
And now for questions:
1. Cosmere - Brandon Sanderson - What I'm reading online about it suggests this is more of a megafandom like Middle-earth (where people often don't read all the books or focus on specific parts within it) than a specific series like ASoIaF. If not given evidence otherwise, I will split this up into the following categories:
2. Crossover Groups: Group: Diana (DCU) & Sif (MCU) - I need more specific fandoms for them, especially Diana. Fixed, thanks!
3. The Sandman (Comics): Group: The Kindly Ones - The seems to be a general group, not a specific character. Is there a reason that specific characters can't be used in this specific instance? Exception to rule, along with a few other groups. To be clarified in post later tonight.
4. Wiedźmin | The Witcher - All Media Types- All Media Types is too broad, can this be specified to either the video games or the book? If some of the characters are only found in one or the other and you don't have enough spots, nominator, contact me I can split them myself.
Thanks to anyone who answers, and also to everyone who has nominated so far!
As of the time this posts, all nominations not included in the above questions should be in the tagset. Let me know if they aren't. :D .
And now for questions:
Repeats from last post:
1. Les Misérables - All Media Types is too broad a category - can the person who nominated this narrow it to movie, musical, or book?
2. Steven Universe: Group: Jasper & Ruby Squad - Ruby Squad seems to be a group and not a character as far as I can tell - is there a specific Ruby Squad character?
3. Fullmetal Alchemist: Envy - Everything I can find online is describing Envy as either male or genderless. Am I looking at the wrong character or is there a justification for Envy being female?
1. Cosmere - Brandon Sanderson - What I'm reading online about it suggests this is more of a megafandom like Middle-earth (where people often don't read all the books or focus on specific parts within it) than a specific series like ASoIaF. If not given evidence otherwise, I will split this up into the following categories:
- Fandom: Stormlight Archive - Brandon Sanderson; Characters: Jasnah Kholin, Shallan Davar, Navani Kholin; Lift (Stormlight Archive)
- Vin (Mistborn), MeLaan (Mistborn)
- Fandom: The Alloy of Law - Brandon Sanderson; Characters: Marasi Colms, MeLaan (Alloy of Law)
- Fandom: Warbreaker - Brandon Sanderson; Characters: Sisirinah (Warbreaker)
4. Wiedźmin | The Witcher - All Media Types- All Media Types is too broad, can this be specified to either the video games or the book? If some of the characters are only found in one or the other and you don't have enough spots, nominator, contact me I can split them myself.
Thanks to anyone who answers, and also to everyone who has nominated so far!
As of the time this posts, all nominations not included in the above questions should be in the tagset. Let me know if they aren't. :D .
Questions and info from the mod, part 2:
May. 29th, 2018 06:52 pmladybrooke1. I will be out of town for most the day tomorrow (May 30th) for a meeting - I should be back in time to do some work on the tagset, but if you don't get a response to these until later tomorrow, that's why.
The following are specific nomination questions, fandoms/nom bolded:
2. Mass Effect nominator(s) - I assumed that you were nomming as a specific part of the franchise due to the lack of an All Media tag, but other participants have said some of the characters do not appear in that part. Can you contact me or comment below and let me know what you meant? Fixed, thanks!
3. Sense8: "Group: Sun Bak & Her Assistance" - Googling is not helping me figure out this one. Is there a typo in it, or can you point me to info about the second part? Fixed, thanks!
4. Les Misérables - All Media Types is too broad a category - can the person who nominated this narrow it to movie, musical, or book?
5. Steven Universe: Group: Jasper & Ruby Squad - Ruby Squad seems to be a group and not a character as far as I can tell - is there a specific Ruby Squad character?
6. Fullmetal Alchemist: Envy - Everything I can find online is describing Envy as either male or genderless. Am I looking at the wrong character or is there a justification for Envy being female?
7. A hold over from last post - MCU is too broad a category for this exchange, can the nominator please edit or let me know where they want those character noms to go? Fixed, thanks!
The following are specific nomination questions, fandoms/nom bolded:
4. Les Misérables - All Media Types is too broad a category - can the person who nominated this narrow it to movie, musical, or book?
5. Steven Universe: Group: Jasper & Ruby Squad - Ruby Squad seems to be a group and not a character as far as I can tell - is there a specific Ruby Squad character?
6. Fullmetal Alchemist: Envy - Everything I can find online is describing Envy as either male or genderless. Am I looking at the wrong character or is there a justification for Envy being female?
Questions and info from the mod, part 1:
May. 25th, 2018 07:42 pmladybrookeGroup: Gamora & ValkyrieGroup: Nebula & ShuriGroup: Nebula & ValkyrieGroup: Okoye & Valkyrie
3. MCU, Arrowverse, and
Thanks for reading this & any answers, everyone!
