Tagset Questions
May. 9th, 2017 10:03 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
pumpkinkingmod posting in ![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png){kind=small}
everywomanTagset
All fandoms, “characters”, and canon helpers that I do not have questions about have been accepted or rejected. If you look at the bottom of the tagset you can see there are many that I need to create associations for. If something you nominated was rejected then check to make sure it isn’t already under the tagset under a different name or in the unassociated tags section.
As an apology for my date mix up you may comment with up to two characters or groups on this post for me to add to the tagset. The only stipulations are that they must already be formatted so that I can just copy and paste and it must be for a fandom that is already in the tagset. I will also add any additional canon helpers requested for fandoms that are in the tagset.
I believe I got all the corrections that I was told about. If I missed some or you discover new ones then you can comment on this post.
Class (TV 2016)
Andra'ath | Andrea Quill – This was the only thing nominated here. This is a Doctor Who spinoff, right? Would anyone be terribly upset if I just threw her in to the Doctor Who tags? I would add a canon helper.
DC TV Shared Universe
Killer Frost (Arrowverse) – Earth 1 or Earth 2 Killer Frost? If Earth 1 is meant then how distinct from Caitlin is Killer Frost?
Discworld - Terry Pratchett
CH: Witches and wizards – Is this a specific book or subsection of books?
Marvel (Comics)
Loki (Agent of Asgard) – I’m only familiar with movie Loki. I’d like someone to state a case on how they could be interpreted as a female character, you don’t need to be the nominator to do so.
Marvel Cinematic Universe
CH: Women in S.H.I.E.L.D. – Is this a specific spinoff?
Original Work
Group: Intelligent Bonobo Alien Alpha Female & Female Human Intergalactic Ambassador – What is a Bonobo alien?
Pacific Rim (Movies)
CH: Shatterdome Operations – Is this a specific part of canon about this? I’m generally allowing in events set before or after a canon, but I’m unsure about this.
CH: Tech Girls – Is this a specific part of canon?
Star Trek
Kesh (Star Trek) – I’ve only found reference to a male character with this name
Stargate - All Media Types
CH: Off-World – Is there a particular part of canon about this?
CH: Pegasus Cultures – Is there a particular part of canon about this?
The Hobbit/The Lord of the Rings - All Media Types
Fíriel Fairbairn – Would this character make more sense under The Silmarillion and other histories of Middle-Earth - J. R. R. Tolkien?
Group: Nimrodel & Mithrellas (H/LotR) – Should this be left here or moved to the Silmarillion?
The Sandman (Comics)
Group: The Kindly Ones – I prefer to have a fixed number of characters in a group. I also can’t find much info on the Kindly ones.
The Silenced (2015)
Joo-ran
Shizuko – The Wikipedia entry doesn’t make it clear how distinct Joo-Ran and Shizuko are from each other. Can you please elaborate or give me a similar example from another canon?
The Silmarillion and other histories of Middle-Earth - J. R. R. Tolkien
Gereth- The only wiki mention I can find of Gereth uses male pronouns. Is this a case of having an unclear gender in canon and the wiki just using masculine ones for ease?
The Wicked Years Series - Gregory Maguire
Someone had nominated Wicked under Oz – All Media Types. Now that the books have been nominated would you prefer that Wicked stay where it is, get moved here, or that this gets combined into the All Media Types?
All fandoms, “characters”, and canon helpers that I do not have questions about have been accepted or rejected. If you look at the bottom of the tagset you can see there are many that I need to create associations for. If something you nominated was rejected then check to make sure it isn’t already under the tagset under a different name or in the unassociated tags section.
As an apology for my date mix up you may comment with up to two characters or groups on this post for me to add to the tagset. The only stipulations are that they must already be formatted so that I can just copy and paste and it must be for a fandom that is already in the tagset. I will also add any additional canon helpers requested for fandoms that are in the tagset.
I believe I got all the corrections that I was told about. If I missed some or you discover new ones then you can comment on this post.
Andra'ath | Andrea Quill – This was the only thing nominated here. This is a Doctor Who spinoff, right? Would anyone be terribly upset if I just threw her in to the Doctor Who tags? I would add a canon helper.
DC TV Shared Universe
Killer Frost (Arrowverse) – Earth 1 or Earth 2 Killer Frost? If Earth 1 is meant then how distinct from Caitlin is Killer Frost?
Discworld - Terry Pratchett
CH: Witches and wizards – Is this a specific book or subsection of books?
Marvel (Comics)
Loki (Agent of Asgard) – I’m only familiar with movie Loki. I’d like someone to state a case on how they could be interpreted as a female character, you don’t need to be the nominator to do so.
CH: Women in S.H.I.E.L.D. – Is this a specific spinoff?
Group: Intelligent Bonobo Alien Alpha Female & Female Human Intergalactic Ambassador – What is a Bonobo alien?
CH: Shatterdome Operations – Is this a specific part of canon about this? I’m generally allowing in events set before or after a canon, but I’m unsure about this.
CH: Tech Girls – Is this a specific part of canon?
Kesh (Star Trek) – I’ve only found reference to a male character with this name
CH: Off-World – Is there a particular part of canon about this?
CH: Pegasus Cultures – Is there a particular part of canon about this?
Fíriel Fairbairn – Would this character make more sense under The Silmarillion and other histories of Middle-Earth - J. R. R. Tolkien?
Group: Nimrodel & Mithrellas (H/LotR) – Should this be left here or moved to the Silmarillion?
Group: The Kindly Ones – I prefer to have a fixed number of characters in a group. I also can’t find much info on the Kindly ones.
The Silenced (2015)
Joo-ran
Shizuko – The Wikipedia entry doesn’t make it clear how distinct Joo-Ran and Shizuko are from each other. Can you please elaborate or give me a similar example from another canon?
Gereth- The only wiki mention I can find of Gereth uses male pronouns. Is this a case of having an unclear gender in canon and the wiki just using masculine ones for ease?
Someone had nominated Wicked under Oz – All Media Types. Now that the books have been nominated would you prefer that Wicked stay where it is, get moved here, or that this gets combined into the All Media Types?
