Nominations Clarifications #2

[everywomanmods]

Nominations close tomorrow and we have another set of questions.

Divergent - All Media Types
Mods don't know enough about the book vs film differences to know whether this is a reasonable use of the AMT tag. Fandom, any thoughts?

Game of Thrones (TV)
If you still have unapproved nominations here, they're duplicates - feel free to replace with something else, or we'll edit to match what's in the tagset & approve them.

God Wars: Future Past
Nominator, we don't accept / ships. Please either edit to the correct group format, or replace with single characters or groups that you would be okay not being guaranteed an / ship for. We will edit to the correct group form if not fixed by the time signups open.

Marvel Cinematic Universe
Please renominate "Group: Jessica Jones (The Defenders TV) and Michelle Jones (MCU Movies Only)" under Crossover Fandom. If you don't have enough slots for that, let us know and we'll add it in for you manually.

Original Works
Nominator of "Group : Archeologist & her dog", please clarify how/why the dog should be considered a female character. As currently phrased we're tempted to reject, but open to hearing your reasoning.

Pacific Rim (Movies)
Do Angela Hansen or Tamsin Sevier appear in the movies? If they don't but that's where fandom is used to having them, let us know.

Sharp Objects
Was "Group: Joya Preaker and Adora Crellin" meant to be associated with the book or the tv show?

The Silmarillion and other histories of Middle-Earth - J. R. R. Tolkien
Finduilas nominator, your Tolkien mods are 99% sure you mean Finduilas the Noldor and not Finduilas of Dol Amroth, but just wanted to double check.

英雄伝説 閃の軌跡 | Sen no Kiseki | The Legend of Heroes: Trails of Cold Steel
Nominator, we don't accept / ships. Please either edit to the correct group format, or replace with single characters or groups that you would be okay not being guaranteed an / ship for. We will edit to the correct group form if not fixed by the time signups open.

Comments

[facethestrange]

In 5 of my Crossover Fandoms nominations I forgot to add the "Group:" part, and they already got approved this way. In case you want to change it, they are:
Agnes Nutter (Good Omens) and Gytha "Nanny" Ogg and Esmerelda "Granny" Weatherwax (Discworld)
Margo Hanson (The Magicians (TV)) and Daenerys Targaryen (ASOIAF)
Margo Hanson (The Magicians (TV)) and Sansa Stark (ASOIAF)
Vanya Hargreeves (The Umbrella Academy (TV)) and Alice Quinn (The Magicians (TV))
Vanya Hargreeves (The Umbrella Academy (TV)) and Julia Wicker (The Magicians (TV))

The only other nomination in Crossover Fandom without the "Group:" part (not mine anymore) is "Natasha Romanov (Mcu) & Felicia Hardy (spider-man ps4 game)", and it also has the & sign, so I thought I'd let you know about it too.

ETA:

There's also a duplicate under The Magicians (TV): "Julia Wicker (Magicians TV)" and "Julia Wicker (The Magicians (TV))".

[everywomanmods]

Thanks for letting us know! We'll get to those tomorrow during tagset cleanup.

[(Anonymous)]

Pacific Rim (Movies)

No, neither Angela Hansen or Tamsin Sevier appear in the movies, but that's where they're usually found since (so far as I know), Pacific Rim doesn't have a separated out section for characters who appear in the secondary media.

[everywomanmods]

Thanks for clarifying, we've accepted them under "Pacific Rim (Movies)"

[tehexile]

fixed mine

Finduilas

[(Anonymous)]

Hi! Yes, Finduilas Faelivrin of the Noldor was what I meant - sorry for the confusion!

Re: Finduilas

[everywomanmods]

No problem, just wanted to make sure - she's been accepted.

[(Anonymous)]

For Sharp Objects I would prefer book, but it doesn't really matter. (Nominator)

[everywomanmods]

Thanks, we've associated it with the book!

[entwinedlove]

Under TV Shows > Outlander, "Jenny Fraser Murray (Outlander TV)" is listed twice.

[everywomanmods]

Thanks, we've removed the duplicate!

[shadaras]

You'll probably get a new post up soon, but some duplicates I found while thinking about last-minute noms:

Group: Jyn Erso and Enfys Nest (Rogue One)
Group: Jyn Erso and Enfys Nest (Rogue One)

Group: Jyn Erso and Leia Organa (Rogue One)
Group: Jyn Erso and Leia Organa (Rogue One)

Group: Jyn Erso and Lyra Erso (Rogue One)
Group: Jyn Erso and Lyra Erso (Rogue One)

[everywomanmods]

Thank you, I've removed those duplicates!

[zdenka]

I noticed some duplicates. Under Phantom of the Opera - Lloyd Webber (11), these groups are all duplicated with an identical tag:

Group: Christine Daaé and Carlotta Giudicelli (Phantom)
Group: Christine Daaé and Carlotta Giudicelli (Phantom)
Group: Christine Daaé and Meg Giry (Phantom)
Group: Christine Daaé and Meg Giry (Phantom)
Group: Madame Giry and Christine Daaé (Phantom)
Group: Madame Giry and Christine Daaé (Phantom)
Group: Madame Giry and Meg Giry (Phantom)
Group: Madame Giry and Meg Giry (Phantom)

[everywomanmods]

Thanks, I've removed the duplicates!

Mimi Typo?

[(Anonymous)]

In the Baby-Sitters Club tags there’s “ L "Mimi" Yamamoto” and I think it’s a typo to have the L at the front. I’m not in the fandom, but on the wiki page and from what I remember in the books she’s only referred to as Mimi Yamamoto. The nominator can correct me if I’m wrong though.

Re: Mimi Typo?

[desertvixen]

That's the tag that pops up when you try to put Mimi in - I'm not opposed to it being changed. (Nominator)

[elleth]

There are a couple of duplicates in the Stand Still Stay Silent tag set:

Siv Västerström (SSSS)
Sointu Takasuo (SSSS)
Taru Hollola (SSSS)
Tuulikki Hotakainen (SSSS)
Tuuri Hotakainen (SSSS)

[everywomanmods]

Thanks, we've removed those!